About PEMBlogNewsResourcesContact Us
News & Events

Parents for Ethical Marketing
is a young, grassroots organization of people concerned about the effects of corporate marketing practices directed at young children.

Members receive action alerts and a monthly e-newsletter.

Learn More...

Donate
News & Events

Monthly E-News Archive

Read More...

 

Parents for Ethical Marketing on Facebook and Twitter

On Facebook? Become a fan of PEM! Or follow me on Twitter!

Read More...

 

HealthyToys.org Lead Check

Lead content in toys? Find out now.

Read More...

Censorship defined, or, Don’t worry, stimulating Bratz books still available to kids

CCFC is a getting some good press since Scholastic decided to drop the Bratz brand from their school offerings. I have to say, though, that I’m taken aback by all the people likening Scholastic’s decision to “censorship.”

We’re not talking about a public library here, or even a school library. Scholastic is a for-profit corporation.

This ain’t censorship.

(And if you really want to get your hands on some Bratz books, looks like Amazon only has about 250 titles to choose from.) 

Unfortunately, children in public schools are a captive audience who have no choice but to be the target of Scholastic’s product pitches.

It’s funny: I’m always hearing that it’s the parents’ responsibility to say no to their kids and to let the free market work. Isn’t that just what happened here? I took the responsibility to let my girls know that Bratz-branded products are not allowed in our  house. And as a Scholastic customer, I let Scholastic know that I would not be purchasing Bratz books from them. So did many other parents. Scholastic responded by dropping the Bratz books from their product line. How is this censorship? Isn’t Scholastic just responding to their market?

You can still help Parents for Ethical Marketing win $100 by clicking over to MOMboTV. Today’s suggested post: An interview with Ted Ning from Lifestyles of Health and Sustainability (LOHAS). LOHAS encourages business leaders to be more responsive to the needs of socially-conscious consumers.

2 Responses to “Censorship defined, or, Don’t worry, stimulating Bratz books still available to kids”

  1. Derek Says:

    Because most people don’t really understand what a “free market” really means. And most people who support kids being a captive audience in government schools (i.e. no school choice), and cry “censorship” when parents assert themselves really don’t support the free market anyway.

  2. mom Says:

    Yes, yes. Some people in the business world actually think that listening to their consumer base is a good idea.

Leave a Reply