About PEMBlogResources

Archive for March, 2010

How our tax dollars subsidize corporate marketing so kids can smoke, eat junk food, and hate themselves

Tuesday, March 30th, 2010

Recently we’ve seen an increase in impending government legislation created to protect children.

For example, the Healthy Media for Youth Act was recently introduced in Congress. The bill would create media literacy programs, promote research on the effect of media images on kids, and encourage the adoption of voluntary guidelines to promote healthier media images of girls and women. The bill was developed in collaboration with the Girl Scouts.

obama_child

Next,  the Food and Drug Administration (with its newfound authority) has issued rules restricting tobacco industry marketing and sales to youth. Nice timing, considering that we just learned how the RJ Reynolds’ pink Camel No. 9 campaign targeted young teenage girls.

The rules, which take effect on June 22, will ban all remaining tobacco-brand sponsorships of sports/entertainment events;  address outdoor tobacco advertising near schools and playgrounds; and restrict tobacco ads to black-and-white text only in publications that teens read and at point-of-sale.

Then there’s the newly formed Task Force on Childhood Obesity, made up of the Departments of Agriculture, Health and Human Services, and  Education. It has recently requested comments to inform upcoming policy decisions.

The official Presidential Memo directs the Task Force to focus on four issues: ensuring access to healthy, affordable food; increasing physical activity in schools and communities; providing healthier food in schools; and empowering parents with information and tools to make good choices for themselves and their families.

Childhood obesity concerns have also prompted the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010, which directs the Department of Agriculture to set new nutrition standards for food served in schools, including vending machine offerings. The current laws are almost thirty years old.

Finally, the Federal Trade Commission is requesting comments on its reevaluation of the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA). Among other things, COPPA governs what information companies can collect online from children under age 13. Changes in technology and how children use the internet and social media prompted the review.

That’s a lot of legislation and it’s all essentially designed to protect kids from corporate marketing. I truly wish all this legislation wasn’t necessary. But we know that allowing industry self-regulation doesn’t work and that corporations are not going to do much more on their own. Not when they can continue to profit from recruiting brand ambassadors.

And remember, while Washington is spending our tax dollars creating task forces and legislative actions and holding press conferences and gathering comments? Corporations continue to deduct their advertising and marketing expenses from their federal taxes.

So essentially, our tax dollars pay for the ads that sell tobacco and junk food and promote unhealthy body images to our kids.

What’s wrong with this picture?

Read also: Jill Richardson’s Behind the Shady World of Marketing Junk Food to Children and Lousy School Lunch Bill, One Step Closer to Passage and Michele Simon’s Michelle Obama’s Let’s Move – Will it Move Industry?

Image courtesy ex_magician

Updated: “Family-friendly” Disney is nothing but a playground bully

Friday, March 12th, 2010

Update 3/13: Bowing to corporate America, Judge Baker center loses face (Opinion, Boston Globe)

By now you may have heard (or read, in the New York Times) how the multi-billion dollar Disney Corp. saw to it that the Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood, their $250,000 budget and two, count ‘em, two staff members were booted from their home at the Judge Baker Children’s Center.

disneybully

Disney sicked their lawyers on CCFC’s Harvard-based sponsor when they realized that the organization could actually affect their magical brand identity: CCFC had called Disney on their Baby Einstein marketing claims.

It’s a shame. Disney could have taken this opportunity to engage instead of fight.

Although I thought it impossible, my disdain for Disney has reached a new low high.* What to do? There’s a difficulty in taking my business elsewhere, since Disney owns everything. Almost literally. (My 12-year-old has suggested a Year Without Disney. Book deal and Colbert appearance? Hmm.)

Looks like the Judge Baker Center is suffering over its decision. And CCFC lives to advocate another day.

Can you help? Support CCFC.

Read more:

Critics of Baby Einstein DVDs say Disney pressed landlord to evict them (LA Times)
“Mouse Inc?” Disney Bullies Small & Mighty CCFC From Home? (Amy Jussel, Shaping Youth)
Did Disney Threaten a Children’s Mental Health Center? Read Between the Lines (Newsweek)
and All I think about is princesses . . .

Image courtesy bixentro

*3/13 Note to self: Get an editor.

Is media literacy for kids kind of like blaming the victim?

Monday, March 8th, 2010

Congratulations to the Federal Trade Commission for taking on advertising literacy for kids. They’ve recently introduced an online game, Admongo, to help kids better navigate their commercialized world. While playing the game, kids must closely examine fictional ads: Who is responsible for the ad? What is the ad actually saying? What does the ad want me to do?

fakead

Associated resources and a curriculum for grades 5 and 6 are available through Scholastic. (The Scholastic site for parents is coming soon!)

The FTC previously introduced You are Here, a site that also teachers kids about marketing and advertising but  includes lessons on business practices and other topics.

I fully support media literacy, of course. But I can’t help but wonder: What is being done to stop the worst of the worst marketing in the first place?

Commercials Are the Culprit in TV-Obesity Link
Yale Study Finds More Licensed Characters and Other Packaging Promotions Used to Market Less Nutritious Foods to Kids
A Fine Line when Ads and Children Mix
Junk food gets spotlight in many movies: study
BK Kids Meals – Minneapolis’ Campbell Mithun’s Junk Food Client
U-M Researcher Says Preschoolers Understand the Power of Advertising

Just asking.

Over at Mom-101 is a great round-up (in the comments) of what real parents are doing to teach their kids about marketing. I think even Mom-101, a former writer of commercials, would support PEM’s tenets:

– Ethical marketing targets only consumers who can perceive and understand the persuasive tactics in commercials.
– Ethical marketing promotes products that are not harmful to children.
– Ethical marketing supports strong families by respecting parental authority in the parent-child relationship.